@Brail4 @mikemearlsI cant imagine that sleep would NOT be unconscious,but someone insists “its not in the book!” Conditions are meant to be intuitive for the DM to apply. Lack consciousness, as when asleep? Yep, you’re unconscious.
— Jeremy Crawford (@JeremyECrawford) September 27, 2014
Only thing I can think of is Warforged. He’s conscious, he’s just unable to do anything about it.